Wow, just shy of three years since I've talked about Target's favorite day ice cream. It just hasn't caught my attention recently, but then I saw these two weeks ago.

I wasn't sure which New City flavor would be next, but then I got to scoop....

sweet cream ice cream with real birthday cake batter and tons of rainbow sprinkles

[New for 2021] It's weird that I haven't reviewed a topped flavor in forever, but then I remembered that the new sundae flavors came out this year. Also, I do still pick up the strawberry topped tart now and again when I want something really sweet. Anyway, let's finally review...

vanilla ice cream with salted caramel swirls & fudge brownies topped with caramel cups & chocolatey ganache

So the plan was to pick up another pint of New City ice cream at Whole Foods.... but unfortunately all of the new city pints were covered in a literal half inch (or more) of frost and ice. I thought we were coming home empty handed, but then I spied a new brand at Roche Brothers. Let me introduce you to...

black raspberry ice cream with chocolate chips

[New for Fall 2025]  We've been putting most of our energy in to trying all of the cool local places in Worcester County (and beyond), but there is a new blizzard on the menu, so let's order a....

vanilla softserve blended with chewy cookie pieces, buttery toffee and golden caramel

Almost 8 years ago, my in-laws surprised me with an ice cream pie from New City Microcreamery (review here). The plan was to visit one of their scoop shops, but we never did. At some point, their faux pints started showing up in stores, and still I did not try them (we'll blame location). Well, after all this time, I finally decided to try "the best in the world". That's a pretty bold statement...

cream cheese ice cream soaked vanilla cookies with dolce de leche swirl

[New for 2025] Doh, I posted this on instagram but not on the blog. When we were headed back from Jersey at the beginning of summer, we stopped at Wendy's, but I didn't want a sandwich. No no, I wanted...

vanilla frosty with strawberry pop-tart pieces and strawberry sauce

[New for 2025] I keep saying that I am getting more and more frustrated with all of the Kellogg's/Poptart ice cream nonsense.... and then I bring home...

vanilla flavored ice cream sandwiched between two crispy marshmallow squares